Minthara and halsin in party. Ensure Minthara is imprisoned and not executed.
● Minthara and halsin in party Baldur's Gate III is based on a modified version of the Dungeons & Dragons 5th edition (D&D 5e) tabletop RPG Minthara still has some issues with following, joining, and leaving the party in Acts 2 and 3, and Larian Studios is continuing efforts to make her a more viable companion. Gather your party and venture forth! Could someone share how to keep both Minthara and Halsin, I heard its doable now. With Minthara, Halsin will hang outside of Minthara's tent where his ought to be. Thanks to Reddit user u/DJay_lost for sharing this method. Both Minthara and Halsin are in your camp and they don't hate Halsin and Minthara should not be possible and it is a bug probably. The next day, I found Minthara in Zevlor's cave. The Grove will be decimated (along with the shopkeeper), Halsin will be unavailable and the Shadow Curse After obtaining Minthara, decline to put her in the active party as many of the cultists will now have a grudge against the Drow Paladin. trying to test out another theory whether I can have whll and karlach will still follow along if I’m able to recruit minthara by skipping the Druid Gather your party and venture forth! The issue I'm having is I tried to ignore Halsin and Minthara missions by not picking a side to see if I can get both, I just went straight into act 2, I got Minthara in act 2 and snuck her out of the tower then told her to meet me at camp, I got to camp and shes not there but her tent is for the rest of It is possible to recruit both Minthara and Halsin in Act 2. Minthara: She was a high priestess of House Vandree. General Questions - [SPOILERS] I just plain and simple don't like druids. All this must be done without a long rest. Note, there isn't enough beds for all the companions so halsin is left without a bed. First, somewhere in Act 1, you’ll get a choice of joining the Absolute or helping the Druid Grove. I do like minthara and I enjoy having her in my party but its also very plain that a lot of the story is just kinda busted as a result. this is similar to Baldurs Gate 2 Slayer. In brief: yes, you can side with the goblins, have a fun night with Minthara, dodge Then you can have a moment in act 2 when you can decide to have Halsin join the party, or to have Halsin stay behind and bring Kagha along on a sort of pilgrimage or learning tour. Exit the dungeon, kill now-hostile (everyone in the temple will be as soon as they see the bear) goblins including the inevitable arriving patrolling guard. Find Thaniel. Then at the end of Act 2, after liberating the Nightsong and hiring Jaheira , Minthra suddenly disappeared without saying a word and without any notification that she left. He is being a hypocrite making exceptions for a Vampire Spawn, a Sharran, a warlock, and a mage with an explosive in his chest. Make her temp hostile, go to goblin camp, run straight for minthara, make temp hostile, use non lethal attks to knock her out, then kill the rest of the leaders, get halsin and leave. Halsin and Minthara will likewise not acknowledge one another and their camps will overlap as they aren't supposed to be in the same party by default. Halsin was at the party, enjoying the "stimulating company" of goblins and especially happy not to be in charge of the grove anymore . She doesn't have anything to say about Halsin. The quest markers are still on the map, pointing to Gut and other guy’s bodies. Halsin Will Not Join If You Side With Minthara. If the goblin forces are defeated and Minthara is pretty sure he means how did you get all the companions without them randomly quitting the party? siding with minthara alone nromally makes will, karlach and halsin instantly abandon you. 6 - Save halflings, save zevlor and finish the act. Knocked her out at the Goblin Camp (I handled her second and immediately went to Dror who I attacked while he was talking to the dead mindflayer and received the necessary Quest completions) However Minthara is very bugged, and even though she has lines acknowledging Wyll and Karlach they also have some lines referencing her which you can't normally hear. Sort by: Force Minthara to join party . So, I am doing a "good" run, and I saved the Grove and tiefling. Just hanging around the main hall. 6) You progress the quest from Halsin until he offers to become permanent companion. So the choice I have right now is, do the grove quest to keep Karlach and Wyll and This feels incredibly misguided, especially when Halsin (the other Act 2 companion) has zero issues leaving to travel to Act 1 areas. Reason why I have these 4 together. r/BaldursGate3. (I’m at the outdoors campsite) THEN I FIND THIS MAN WHITTLING AWAY UP THE First rescue Halsin from jail, but don't recruit him into your party. if minthara is not in your party then it will not trigger Halsin and Minthara are NEVER meant to be at the same party. Before talking to Minthara, collect Karlach and Wyll. Minthara has just completely disappeared. Halsin will be there. SPOILER. So since we can get Minthara without killing the grove, I'm doing that. You're not supposed to have both Halsin or Minthara in a single playthrough. She Gather your party and venture forth! I agree, because at least before minthara and halsin had separate camp spots in the Lower City campsite, but for me post patch Halsin has no tent anywhere and just awkwardly stands around other peoples tents Reply reply More replies. Because this will remove Halsin from the campaign, it will be better to check the state of the Halsin's quests in ACT 2 before you play this cutscene. Be aware tho that if you manage to get Halsin and Minthara, the latter won't have a tent at camp as they both use the same spot. At least for me, it's always been that way, so it seems So, I am doing a "good" run, and I saved the Grove and tiefling. Talking to Zevlor and telling him I had joined the dark side to raid the grove I still lose Wyll but seemingly not Karlach. then you go to the goblin camp and kill all gobbos and leaders BUT you do not touch Minthara. Minthara, while being part of quests, never has her own quest in the quest log unlike Jaheira with Danthelon Dancing Axe and Halsin with Art Cullagh and Thaniel. Then I remembered Halsin. Maybe not necessarily Minthara in other cases, the point is Thaniel stands beside someone other than Halsin. Meet up with the goblin party after traveling through the mountain pass. My current idea is kill Minthara drag her body back to the grove and use revivify to bring her back. Open comment sort options. The sequence is you first speak with the girl right next to the man sleeping, then speak with halsin in your camp, then speak with halsin in Las Light Inn, then go to the house of healing and kill the boss to get a lute, comeback to speak with halsin, do the portal encounter, then go to the house with flowers meet Oliver, then speak about it It would be really interesting if there was an option where you could avoid Minthara but still wipe out the goblins and save the grove. Ensure Minthara is imprisoned and not executed. Minthara: I took my first lover before you were a spark in your father's eye, child. I also want to save the grove, but don’t know how to do that as Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • Fuzzy_Difficulty_668 In a long term perspective, you can Halsin or Minthara. Minthara is a Drow Gather your party and venture forth! Rescue halsin like normal, talk to Minthara but don’t get into a fight through dialogue. Looks like this is a mess and i have to re-do act I. Treat that as a privilege, not as a platform to ask for more in this context. For that to work, you have to start one of their romances in Act 1 and then make sure to pick flirting dialogue with Halsin during the course of the game (explicitly flirt at the grove party and ask about his love life when getting to know him dialogue becomes available). For Minthara you'd have to do the sheep glitch or if you're on pc, get the mod. Keep Halsin alive. So far so good. I think this upsets Halsin so he disappears a lot and sometimes just pops up in random places in camp, Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online. Mod name Notes; Baldur's Gate 3 Mod Fixer : Drow Priestess Robe Gather your party and venture forth! and Astarion are by withers each with a bed, and shart, Minsc, Wyll, jaheira, and minthara/halsin are in the area off the side opposite the resting bed, and halsin takes the hallway floor if you have minthara on your team I believe Has lead to some awkward moments 😅 Minthara was sitting right there last night when Halsin propositioned my Tav, and presumably noticed when he snuck off later that night Fast-forward to this morning when she asks to read Tav’s thoughts, and I can only assume Tav and Halsin are exchanging glances over her shoulder knowing those thoughts are going to be full of a certain The designated way to gain Minthara was to kill Tieflings and Halsin. Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online. I plan to knock out minthara while kill all the goblins so she will be at the moonrise for be recruit. Oh no, in all of Act 2, they are happily bunking together. Her dying normally allows haslin to come. So playing the "good guy" for my first run but I still want all possible companions. More results: If I rush to Moonrise, but don't enter the cutscene with Ketheric punishing Minthara, and return to act I, Halsin is dead, but Minthara is back in her spot. I remember seeing a post saying in a new patch you can recruit both by knocking out minthara in act 1. Requirements . Also, some Act 3 camp spots don't have separate tents for them, but the "main" camp spot (anywhere in the city) they do have separate spots. The developers at Larian Studios saw the plot issues of Halsin and Minthara remaining in the party together and how their history and opposing values would be incompatible. Now that I have both characters in my party, Minthara's tent has loaded in, in the place of Halsin's tent where Minthara stands quietly with Thaniel. I had Minthara in my party, completed the Ketheric fight and Minthara left my party The party can first meet Halsin during their trip to the Goblin Camp, a major step in the main quest of Act One. But now that you can have both Halsin and Minthara, I had the thought: Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online. Their intended quest lines involve thwarting the other. Minthara seems way more interesting and complex than Halsin, who has the personality of a sack filled with leaves and twigs. You can now recruit Minthara while still siding with the Tieflings without having to use magic rings. ADMIN MOD Halsin and Minthara camp are overlapping General Discussion - [SPOILERS] Share Sort by: Best. Anyway, Wyll still leaves at the party even though he stuck around after everything else happened, but only leaves after Minthara raids an already empty grove without you. I ♥♥♥♥ you not. It is currently unknown if we'll see Halsin again after the event. ”" Minthara: "Just give the word and I will kill the clown. A few more interesting things occur when I bring one out in my party. Saving Halsin & Minthara Origin Characters I have free sazza the goblin and halsin from the cage. If you try to fast travel back to the Act 1 region with Minthara in the party, she will open dialog with you and flat out refuse to leave the Moonrise region. Ugh, doing my first tactician playthrough and really need that cave bear for Ragzlin lol. Yes, you can recruit both Minthara and Halsin. That means we’ll need to go to the Goblin Camp and defeat the 3 leaders. Recruited Minthara in prison, escaped via back-side of tower. She can also be romanced. Either way, there should be a way to spare in Act I and then recruit her in Act II (just like if you play the "evil" methods). Any chance this could work? Related Topics Baldur's Gate Role-playing video game Gaming comments sorted . I think it was because of the sequence of events I took. I imagine this was the original intention for Halsin until he become a fan favorite during early access along with Minthara (who at least is a different class than anyone else). Sazza will be ready to be saved again. Minthara never bugged out on me either like some ppl Technically, the only change made with Patch #5 in this matter is that Halsin will not automatically die if Minthara is alive at the very first instant the player party sets foot beyond the boundaries of Act 1. Roah will be available to you later as a quest NPC/trader. Party with some Tiefs. Knocking Out Minthara. To do so you must enable non-lethal attack and knock her out while doing the "kill the three leaders" quest for Zevlor/Halsin. The only real switch is Karlach and Minthara, but I intend to keep that slot for a melee focused character to balance my Tav and Gale as spellcasters. Reply reply Top 1% Rank by size . Minthara: I adored her, and had been sharing her bed for At least she didn't for me. We’ll need to help the Druid Grove for this to work. That changes a lot of things. Halsin then cheerfully stands, usually, near Withers. A community all about Baldur's Gate III, the role-playing video game by Larian Studios. Now that Minthara is en route, go to Halsin. 7) done :-D or is it this one? Not 100% tested yet, but the following steps seem to work: Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • Halsin will kill you, trying to test out another theory whether I can have whll and karlach will still follow along if I’m able to recruit minthara by skipping the Druid and goblin conflict. I looted the grove and went to the goblin party with her. " “try it and I’ll gut them and cut your hands off, I don’t like to share Tav: "Minthara tell the one about the drow who married a drider. If you rescue Halsin, he will force you to wipe out the goblin (that includes minthara, even though you already recruited her). I was able to go back to the grove, have my party, romance my Would say Minthara and Halsin both, but at least Halsin has a quest. (I’m at the outdoors campsite) THEN I FIND THIS MAN WHITTLING AWAY UP THE STAIRS OF THE DESTROYED HOUSE WHERE THE MIRROR IS. That means going to Last Light Inn and looking for Thaniel to recruit Halsin and going to Moonrise Minthara can be saved and recruited to the party. Okay, just the one “Grace is bestowed by nature, not me. Gather your party and venture forth! (I saved the grove) and I got SO confused when I saw Minthara where Halsin usually is. After killing everyone but left Minthara knocked down, I went back and escaped with Halsin, Then I went to the Grove and turned his quest, got all the rewards, I even stole the Idol for Mol. There are other repercussions for getting the two faction Gather your party and venture forth! I went into the game completely blind and I prefer Minthara WAY MORE than I do Halsin. The other companions have acknowledged Minthara, but Halsins just keeps talking about the shadow curse. I just plain and simple don't like druids. #1. Any dialogue with Minthara and Halsin (probably anyone else too) after this is as if I was personally responsible for killing the grove inhabitants. BG3 is the third main game in the Baldur's Gate series. He tells me the quests are satisfied, everything's great, and he'll meet me at the grove. New. Sazza and Minthara should still be there, but Sazza will probably be pissed and not want to talk, so you'll have to give her ~100-200 gold to get her attitude back into orange. From what others have said Halsin should have left, but now they share a tent :/. Reply reply Halsin and Minthara are two opposing companions in Baldur’s Gate 3. Minthara joined my party in Act 2. Be warned that Minthara can be buggy no matter what, especially if you recruit her through the non-normal method (knocking her out vs siding with her against the Grove). I did so and now I'm in act 2 at moonrise, but Also, you do not have to clear the entire camp in a single day. Help him, and kill all of the goblins in the room. the devs definitely did account for this, there is a line of dialogue where the dream visitor comments Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • ma_dude28. With Minthara I hope they add some interactions between Minthara and Halsin in the next patch or hot fix. kill the 2 goblin leaders and tell halsin to stay in his cage go to moonrise and recruit minthara put minthara in your party go back to the goblin camp and go to where minthara used to be while she's in your party kill minthara who you brought with you then go to halsin and he will join you revive minthara at your camp As of Full Release Patch 1, it's impossible to recruit Minthara and Halsin. i painted Minthara and Moonrise Tower! 2. You already are fairly limited on party members for an evil run (losing Wyll and Karlach and possibly Gale), and this greatly limits the order in which you can play the areas. Kill the other bosses as usual. Halsin permanently leaves the party. This mod will make it so defeating her whether at the Goblin Camp or during the Raid does not kill Keep Halsin alive. At the Emerald Grove, the party must side with the tieflings. Minthara will be in a jail in Moon Towers as she supposed to be. No, in the current state of the game, recruiting Halsin requires you to kill the three leaders of goblin camp, Minthara included. This is what you need to do to recruit Minthara and stay good. Tell him to wait. 3) Now apparently (I haven't tried it yet in Patch 7) added some acknowledgement of the knockout to Minthara's Minthara sets a future rendezvous point in Act 2. I succeeded, there were some weird interactions like both Minthara and Halsin standing next to Thaniel like a small family (it was more concerning than wholesome) and the first time I talked to Minthara in camp she just straight up spoiled the entire plot of act 3 (lucky me I already Minthara: I took my first lover before you were a spark in your father's eye, child. She does express wanting to get revenge on Orin and there is a dialogue after you kill her but it doesnt matter if she was there or not and theres no quest Halsin is a cool character but the spot of party Druid is already filled by Jaheira, having two Druid companions but no Bard, Monk or Sorcerer seems a bit strange. Funny thing happened. I haven't done the goblin camp aside from meeting and agreeing to join Minthara. However, siding with the goblins can unlock the companion Minthara, an Halsin is an act 2 and act 3 party member only, and you won’t be able to officially recruit him until after you’ve reached the Last Light Inn in the Shadow-cursed Lands. Right before the fight with Oliver, Halsin offered to join my party, which I agreed to. It would be a good way to conclude the grove vs goblins situation if both of them are in the party. Then tell Minthara you agree to help kill the grove. To get her to join, you must Here, you'll find IGN's complete Walkthrough for unlocking Minthara as an ally during a Good/Neutral run of BG3, including her location and which Rolls to look out for. 9999% sure they don't change the story at all Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • Aries_AyTx. After she escapes, Minthara will join your party as a permanent party member. Find Minthara in the dungeon, enter her mind, rescue her and kill her captors So now that it's possible to recruit Halsin and Minthara both in a good run (save the Tieflings and knock out Minthara while she's temporaily hostile in Goblin camp, (D&D 5e) tabletop RPG ruleset. I would have figured the two mutually exclusive characters are Minthara and Halsin. Enter camp to go get Minthara in my party, end up surprised as heck to find Halsin next to her. Gale will too if his opnion is low and you fail his Halsin does not want to take that chance with Minthara, but can be a total hypocrite taking chances with the existing party. Easily done: go to goblin camp, slaughter everyone BUT when you fight Minthara make sure to toggle non lethal damage on JUST FOR HER, once she's knocked out, slaughter the rest of the goblins; now go to the prison and save Halsin, quest will progress normally, now when you get to the shadowcursed lands you can do whatevs, just make absolutely sure to go to Moonrise So I decided to knock Minthara out, save the Tieflings and have both her and Halsin as an ally. Gather your party and venture forth! Also, it's coded into the game to be able to have both halsin and minthara because she has custom dialog when you ask what she thinks of halsin. With patch #5, as long as Minthara has been knocked out once, the script that is meant to auto-kill Halsin will not run. Have them jump into the chasm. Halsin won’t join your party afaik. Went to Moonrise towers. The quest will also update properly this way like minthara was killed. Moreover, Halsin also had an issue with not moving to your camp after Last It kills me that player controlled Drow don't have a voice actor with the same menacing voicework put into Minthara, the VA for Minthara just oozes that snarling, serpentine Drow feel. She'll be knocked out, her state doesn't change once she's out cold . I'd say go with Minthara though 'cause Halsin is the suckiest, worst written character in the game. After that, the quest progressed normally and the remaining thing to do is to kill Ketheric. Turn on non-lethal and knock her out (final blow can’t be magic or an arrow). She will appear in act 2 and you can get her to join your team. upvotes Changing Minthara recruitment was like altering half a line of code, since all of that was already in place with Sheep-thara method. . She’d be more tied to the MSQ, so I might be willing to let Halsin stay with the Druids even. Halsin romance is soooo wholesome if This guide explains how to recruit Minthara on a “Good Playthrough” in Baldur’s Gate 3 without killing Tieflings. Knocking her out instead of killing her, granting mercy if you lower her life to certain point (like with the hag), or even by dialogue. However, if you’re Recruit Halsin I to your party, who promptly becomes a bear. I have two potential parties depending on if I recruit Minthara or not. any ideas? Because Halsin is not a party member until you finish that quest. Bad news is I haven't gotten any ultimatium. Okay, so as I said I knocked out Minthara, got Halsin out of jail, and then went with him and killed Gut and the other dude. Immediately beeline to Last Light. I recruited her after freeing her from prison. I am over 70hrs into the game and I find this out. And Minthara will struggle to move through the environment in your party. You will need to venture northward, back into the Shadow-Curse, and towards the To add both of them to your party you have to save Halsin and make him wait for you in the prison, then recruit Minthara first and him later in Act 2. I sadly saved Sazza, followed her on bridge but when discovering this thing of having Minthara a So, i had both Minthara and Halsin as companions, i did not chose any side at the end of act 1, Neither saved the druids nor raided them, and as a result of that i was able to recruit both our favorite drow paladin and the focus of the ire of all the easily offended people, the one and only Halsin, haver of bear sex. One of them is Minthara. I dismissed Halsin from my party but that didn't work, she still aggros. Sometimes she will stop entirely, and I Minthara is an optional (and evil) party member in Baldur’s Gate 3. I did have some mods but I'm 99. However, siding with the goblins can unlock the companion Minthara, an Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • Halsin will kill you, whll and karlach are going to leave and gale is the only person that I need to convince to not leave at all. So the choice I have right now is, do the grove quest to keep Karlach and Wyll and possibly get a companion I'll most likely never use or not finish the quest to get Minthara. Recruiting Minthara & Halsin. (Same for Karlach and Wyll, both will leave the party if you try to raid the grove with them) To get them both you have to side with the grove and kill the goblin leaders, but use non-lethal attacks to knock out minthara rather than killing her. Here’s how to rescue Minthara and put her on your team without slaughtering innocents or making half of your party leave permanently. All the Tieflings will make it safely to Act 2. Karlach: Go on. The urge to just start all over to have every companion in my playthrough is driving me mad. If you choose this way, you can capture Minthara and the absolutist attack on the tieflings makes more sense than just attacking travellers. Also if you skip the Grove vs Goblin and go straight to act 2 and save minthara (if you don't want to get your hands dirty while also want to get minthara) Halsin will be found dead in the worg pen. The fact that they allowed an an entire questline to be left unresolved is already a bonus. I just defeated Ketheric in the Mindflayer colony. On my run, I killed the goblins in the courtyard, long rested, and then did everything inside the fort. When in Act 2 area I found my way to Moonrise with the Drider by convincing him to take me. Minthara’s dialogue you can ask her about all companions and there is no option for Halsin. You will keep all party members except Halsin, who dies off-screen. After that I just beat everyone up, and I rescued Halsin, but I told him to stay in the prison. Best. Reply reply Fuzzy_Difficulty_668 • I know I can't have both on my team. In Act II they share a tent because they’re not intended to both be there, but it’s possible. But I heard Minthara is pretty barebones. The male player Drow just sounds so off; the VA works for other congenial races, but it just completely fails at being a proper male drow voice. Now i am in the mission to kill the goblin leaders. People said there would be confrontation. Then you return for Halsin and tell him about the sleeping guy. Killed Dror Ragzlin, which turns the whole camp hostile, killed Gut. I believe (but can not personally confirm) that only knocking out minthara, killing dror ragzlin, saving halsin, and doing the tiefling party has to be done in a single day. as soon as i step into the portal to leave, Minthara disappears. After her disappearance, Halsin's tent will be restored and Halsin will walk back to his original position. Recruiting Minthara: There is no way to recruit both Minthara and Halsin in the same party Minthara seems way more interesting and complex than Halsin, who has the personality of a sack filled with leaves and twigs. After agreeing to seize the grove with Minthara, the party must talk to Halsin and immediately travel to the Emerald Grove. Lost halsin and minthara the same day on honor Mode lol Reunited Thaniel and Oliver without Halsin in party comments. I knocked Minthara unconscious in the Goblin Camp as the Wiki says, So I could save her in Act II. Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • DoorInfamous . He wants me to kill Minthara but im playing as a drow and would like to recruit her to see our interactions. There are datamined dialogues in recent patches implying that it would be possible to recruit Halsin without killing Minthara if Kagha completes the rite of thorns. Minthara is meant to join you on both Act 1 or Act 2, but she only appears in Act 2 if you ignored the grove questline, and thus locked yourself out of Halsin already (unless you exploit the bug Gather your party and venture forth! Thaniel is actually in the camp, but stands beside Minthara, not Halsin. Hmm wait a minute, how do you get back at the grove with Halsin without killing all the goblins leaders ? If I leave without killing Minthara, Halsin stays there and I cant say anything else to Kagha, except that I cant help her You need to kill minthara when she is in your party. This footage is from Act 2 and shows how to recrui We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Top. Reply reply More replies More replies Now it's possible to get both Halsin and Minthara in same party in Act 2 but leaks abd dataminer have allegedly found strings of code for camp dialogue scene that will forces you to choose between Halsin and Minthara in Act 2. After the fight, I saw Minthara's knocked out body on the floor in the room where I fought Gut and her cronies! She was gone after I left and had the victory party. It requires a very specific outcome in Act 1. When Minthara joined the party, Halsin gained inspiration. By which time, Halsin had joined my party permanently. Come home at the end of the night to Drow DommyMommy . Obviously, Minthara doesn't know that Halsin exists at all and I couldn't talk to her about it. Nexus requirements. Im doing a neutral playtrough and just freed Halsin. Share Add a Comment. Minthara was in the cutscene with Ketheric. It's impossible to recruit halsin if you raid the grove. The written interaction is likely to allow the player to follow the story thread of protecting the Druid Grove and keeping Minthara alive so that they can retain Wyll and Karlach in the party. Halsin represents the good path, while Minthara is very evil-aligned. But by keeping both stories unresolved, it becomes possible to recruit the pair together. You can still recruit and have Halsin in your party. It is possible, im in a run with both right now 1-dont trigger the "kill goblin leaders" mission, 2-knock down minthara and kill the other two leaders, 3-dont save Sazza the goblin, dont worry for not triggering the mission, you will save the tieflins and rescue Halsin just the same. I successfully recruited Minthara using the updated Patch 5 knock-out method and she’s been in my party since I rescued her from Moonrise. And Halsin's ultimatum is, likely, a whole cutscene that needs to be scripted, acted, animated and voiced. There is no option that does not involve exploiting a bug or cheating. I have Minthara and got Halsin to help lift the curse, all the thieflings are gone and not at the inn. 5 - Go to camp and you'll see minthara and halsin, now you can recruit halsin to the team. As a good party I might try to fix her, and Halsin could be a huge help back at his Grove. Halsin then joined my party. How do I recruit both Halsin and Minthara? General Discussion - [SPOILERS] I want both characters in my party, but it feels I have to make one choice of killing all of the grove or killing the goblin leaders. Talk to Halsin, exhaust dialogue options with random talking. Apparently they fixed that bug so she dies regardless of being knocked out/added to party then killed and ressed after siding with the grove. After I recruited her, she spawned in the same tent as Halsin, totally 2) Then they fixed the issue with Minthara and Halsin sharing the same tent in camp (they gave it to Minthara). A shame she is locked behind the path of mass slaughter of NPCs with multiple 3 Act storylines, including the Halsin permanently leaves the party. But when talking to Halsin afterwards, he says we still need to take out the leaders. If you come back to act I area and take rest, Minthara will conveniently take up her own post at Goblin camp. Fast travel out to the grove. Minthara is now a full companion at my camp in Act II. My first/current character is a lore bard so I was able to complete a lot of interesting dialogue. Met Halsin in the Alpha, so I somewhat know what he's like. Minthara: I adored her, and had been sharing her bed for some time when the order came that she must die. You’ll just need to do the quest normally but instead of killing Minthara, make sure to knock I just found out that you can have both Minthara and Halsin in your party. So I guess I went straight there, besides meeting the shadow-touched kid. I think it is still a bit bugged, Thaniel just hangs around with Minthara. Like it could be something similar to shadow heart and laezel arguing and talking through things, minus the whole trying the kill each other in the middle of the night. I killed Minthara with a punt to the chasm, and now Halsin refuses to leave the goblin camp. ok so yes in the release there is a way. Spoilers : You go and recruit Karlach and Wyll and do all tasks related to them. With Halsin, I basically completed the Lift the Shadow Curse quest; the only thing left to do is kill Ketheric. Mod name There might be a way to have them in the same party for a moment (like getting minthara before you pick up karlach since the choices to get minthara will not go over well with karlach im sure) but they are on the opposite ends of the alignment chart. Submit a bug report. The kicker being Halsin would refuse to join a party with her, so it’s mutually exclusive, but not “has to be killed”. I knocked her out at the Goblin Camp and proceeded through Acts 1 and 2 as usual- saved the Grove and the Tieflings, helped Halsin find Thaniel, and recruited him to my party. Halsin: "I'm leaving" ;) I'm not a Halsin fan. Is there any workaround for this? I wonder if there are any mods out there that let us get both Halsin and Minthara as full companions without resorting to buggy practices that involves me speed running past the grove? I know its possible, but due to Minthara clearly being unable to talk after saving her from Moonrise I get bugged hard. You should get a scene where you are forced to choose between Minthara and Shadowheart, but it may be bugged because Minthara was a late edittion to the crew. Is there any way to get Halsin as a companion AND raid the grove? Do we get him as companion before the grove raid? You save Minthara and she joins your party. Remember, Halsin is in to threesomes and foursomes. its just a guess. And I rescued Szazz, which I had forgotten. I wish there was a way to spare Minthara's life during Act I while siding with the Tieflings/Druids instead of the goblins. Time to reload :' Reply reply Tierce • Get Minthara first, then go get Halsin for Ragzlin. Follow the caravan to the tower. Recruiting Minthara and Halsin in latest patch Gather your party and venture forth! TLDR: start civil war at grove but don’t fight with either side just leave the grove WITH the idol, “save” Halsin, Give Minthara the location of the grove, Chat with Halsin again and tell him you’re sorry you couldn’t do more, long rest, go to grove and meet with Minthara in Zevlors chamber and One fan figured out how to get Minthara and Halsin in Baldur’s Gate 3 without using mods, and ewe – er, you – can do it too. Advancing the story into the Shadow-Cursed Lands while Minthara is unconscious seems to reliably keep you free from the Fugitive from the Law condition; making So I've been reading up on this and apparently this game-breaker bug needs to be patched asap. More posts you may like Related Baldur's Gate Role-playing video game Gaming forward back. Halsin and all the tieflings randomly died in Halsin is with you in camp, and recruitable in Act 2. A shame she is locked behind the path of mass slaughter of NPCs with multiple 3 Act storylines, including the ¥ÿÿW1Ž Õ^ ‘¦õf>œ ê5æ8ª €f¿‡€ªV qwØ«â× ýóߟ À¸ ‚ÑÄÔÌÜÂÒÊÚÆÖÎÞÁÑÉÙÅÕÍÝÃÓËÛÇ×Ïß ¦Yõ÷¹œ^¤VQb I wish there was a way to spare Minthara's life during Act I while siding with the Tieflings/Druids instead of the goblins. Knocking Minthara out and then long resting before telling Zevlor or Halsin that the party killed the goblin leaders breaks that particular quest, making it impossible to finish. After I recruited her, she spawned in the same tent as Halsin, totally nude (that's my fault, because I robbed her of everything in Act I). Modding will be your friend if you want them both. Then knock out Minthara, but don't talk to her. Additionally, the only "poly" in the game is having Halsin as a side piece when with either Shadowheart or Astarion. Beautiful, elegant, ruthless. We would be praised as heroes. Just don't like em. It’ll take a lot of work, a bit of luck, and one persistent Edit : Just found out : if you kill Halsin afterward, you will still be stuck. I did this and it worked for me. But I think Minthara should Do the tiefling party and go back the next morning to the camp. Clickbait title out of the way! Since everybody's talking about Minthara's recruitment again, I think it's worthwhile to bring up a really helpful guide by u/IjustHaveAsprite who posted a guide a couple of weeks ago on how to recruit Minthara the "good" way without ignoring the Grove/Goblin situation. " Minthara joined my party in Act 2. I'm now at the very beginning of Act 3 (before entering Baldur's Gate), I've searched all over the place in the camp and she's not there. In act 2, I freed Minthara and helped Halsin remove the curse. According to a reddit post from yesterday, in order to have Karlach and Wyll in the same party as Minthara is you have to completely ignore the attack the grove quest. So in a pre-Patch 5/unmodded playthrough, you could simultaneously romance either Astarion or Shadowheart alongside Halsin or Minthara (whichever you recruited). Yes, and they sleep together. Once you’re in Act 2, you can do the recruiting quests for both Minthara and Halsin like normal. You can have both Minthara and Halsin in your party. Halsin makes no mention of her after you recruit her. Minthara even has dialogue for curing the shadow curse, so that's good. However, in EA patch 9, there was a way to get Minthara and Halsin together (technically). She was very happy and thankful. I didn't check Minthara's chambers for fear of messing it up. Halsin will not join your party or even interact with you after the raid if you side with Minthara during the Emerald Grove raid. Just don’t bring Halsin when you’re trying to recruit her. In Act 2 you can rescue Minthara and invite her to your camp. Find and talk to him. ADMIN MOD Halsin and Minthara at camp? Act 2 - Spoilers I just got Minthara to join after infiltrating Moonrise (I saved the grove) and I got SO confused when I saw Minthara where Halsin usually is. Minthara permanently leaves the party. Got ending scenes with both of them and they both thought that I arrived at the post-ending party as their partner. Doing my second playthrough now (half-orc Cleric/Paladin of Selune romancing Shadowheart) and thought it would be fun to try recruiting Minthara. Different from other attempts, in this scenario upon returning to Halsin's corpse, it updates the quest log "He was defeated before he could help us with the parasite" Here are a few things that can forever lock Halsin out from the list of potential companions in a run. Is there a way to have both Minthara and wyll and possible Halsin. And, Minthara will be able to be saved, will be conversational, and will be fully interactable as a normal companion. Find Minthara, fail a couple checks, but she still gets taken to the prison. is it possible that if I transform into Slayer too many times, people will start leaving the party. 4 - Go to the prison and free minthara (no need to save the halfings/gnomes yet) and fight your way out of moonlight tower (around the kitchen counter clockwise from the balcony is the safest way). First kill the goblin and the tiefling in the goblin camp in secret so become invisible and push the tiefling down the hole, let yourself be captured by the goblin, dont free yourself and someone will appear to help you, talk to minthara and say you know the place but cloud your mind, free halsing and make him acompany you but never get close to Shadowheart and Astarion are the only polyamorous companions in the game and only with Halsin. The aftermath of the latest Baldur's Gate 3 Minthara hotfix is another example of this phenomenon, as her recruitment has created yet another hole in the system. Gather your party and venture forth! Minthara + Halsin NOTE: I'd killed Gut, freed Halsin and told him to wait in the Worg pens. You will only miss her scene of celebration in camp with goblins. Ideally I'd like to make it so the teiflings don't die on the road, but I understand that might not be possible with Minthara since 5) You save Minthara and she joins your party. They're getting along famously. That way you could rescue Halsin and still have her alive to show up--though probably furious with you for destroying her plans. Once Halsin is in your camp, talk to him when you reach the Shadow-Cursed Lands in Act 2. She was the sole survivor of the camp in the end. Since patch 5, you can recruit Minthara as your companion and even a romance interest on a good playthrough without killing Tieflings and Druids in Emerald Grove. He will travel to the inn. Killed Malus Thorm, woke up sleeping guy, and helped Halsin get Thaniel. Normally, you get Minthara before you complete that quest since you normally get to the tower before completing it. Act 2. The party can first meet Halsin during their trip to the Goblin Camp, a major step in the main quest of Act One. Have Withers store their souls. anyone know why ? also, I have become the Slayer. On my current playthrough (Durge), I was able to keep Wyll and Halsin and get Minthara no-problem by locking the grove, attempting to betray the grove to Minth, freeing Halsin, and then proceeding on to Act 2 (avoiding her at the grove). Gather your party and venture forth! (I only spared Minthara) And I didn't rescue Halsin until I had Minthara. I thought Halsin would give me an ultimatum, so I did Nathanial's whole thing before going to Moonrise the first time to save Minthara and the other prisoners. But he never shows up. You rescue Halsin and tell him to stay where he is. Here are my ideas: Tav, Minthara, Halsin, and Gale or Tav, Karlach, Halsin, and Gale. If this is true, I question if this is Gather your party and venture forth! Halsin vs Minthara . Halsin is dead and like a serial killer I stored his corpse in my Traveler Chest at camp. You can get her in act 2 this way, and keep everyone except Halsin. She’s a deadly Paladin that wields two blades at once and serves the Cult of the Absolute. All larian did is moved Minthara to moonrise, instead of having us do it through sheep method. Witness Minthara's inquisition. For god sake. His dialogue is different if you already talked to Minthara. Also, BTW, although it came as a surprise to me - people were expecting a confrontation - nah, Halsin gained inspiration when Minthara joined the party. So I knocked Minthara out in Act 1 and rescued her at Moonrise. Previous exploits that allowed this to happen showed that they both occupy the same tent area in camp. vmododrntgfdczgstuzxvzxevalrmcokuemwpeferzjhuq